Cutie Pie Cupcakes is a charming bakery and cake shop in Grove City, PA, known for creating treats that are as memorable as the moments they celebrate. Specializing in cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and cakesicles, this sweet destination brings creativity, flavor, and attention to detail together in every order.
Whether you are planning a birthday, shower, holiday gathering, or just want to surprise someone with something special, Cutie Pie Cupcakes offers custom designs in a wide variety of styles, making each creation feel personal, festive, and one of a kind.
For customers looking for more than an ordinary dessert, this is the kind of bakery that turns simple celebrations into unforgettable experiences.
What makes Cutie Pie Cupcakes especially appealing is the full experience it offers. In addition to custom orders, the bakery also features a food trailer serving cupcakes, milkshakes, cotton candy, and bubble waffles, bringing a fun and exciting twist to events and local visits alike.
The bakery food trailer can even be brought directly to your celebration and set up on site, adding a standout attraction that guests will remember long after the event ends. Cupcake decorating parties add another layer of enjoyment, giving families, friends, and groups a hands-on way to celebrate together.
With delivery and takeaway available, it is easy and convenient to enjoy these unique treats however you prefer. Customers also appreciate the welcoming accessibility of the location, which includes a wheelchair-accessible car park.
Backed by a strong 4.80-star rating from 46 reviews, Cutie Pie Cupcakes has earned a reputation for quality, creativity, and friendly service. Located at 624 E Main St Ext, Grove City, PA 16127, this bakery is a go-to choice for anyone seeking desserts that feel both special and expertly made.
From beautifully decorated custom cakes to playful event treats and crowd-pleasing sweets from the trailer, Cutie Pie Cupcakes delivers the kind of care and originality that helps every occasion shine.
Popular Items
Frequently ordered and highly recommended items at Cutie pie cupcakes
Our Story
Welcome to a place where great food meets warm hospitality. We believe dining is more than just a meal - it's an experience to be savored and shared.
Our kitchen is dedicated to creating dishes that bring people together, using recipes that honor tradition while embracing innovation.
Photos
A glimpse of our restaurant experience
Hear from our valued guests
I ordered a dozen cupcakes for my daughter’s first birthday, I sent McKenzie a picture of something I had in mind. When I picked them up I was completely speechless. They were the prettiest cupcakes I had ever seen and they far exceeded my expectations. Not only were they beautiful but the most delicious cupcakes I’d ever tasted. 10/10 recommend and will be ordering from her for any of my future cupcake needs.
Masters themed cookies for our Masters weekend baby shower were a hit! Decorative and delicious! We were asked for extras to take home for the husbands. Would highly recommend.
We ordered cookies and cupcakes for our daughter’s baby shower. McKenzie did a great job! She was so helpful and easy to work with! The cookies and cupcakes turned out beautiful and were very delicious! I forgot to take a picture of the cupcakes but they were adorable!
McKenzie with Cutie Pie Cupcakes has made numerous birthday cakes for 8 year old daughter over the years and we have never been disappointed. In fact, this year we ordered from a local grocery store only because they had a picture that my daughter loved and wanted on her cake, but that grocery store majorly dropped the ball (didn’t even have our cake ready at all) and my daughters first comment was “that’s is, next time it’s definitely McKenzie making my cake, she NEVER messes them up!”. Any time we have order cakes, there is barely any left because everyone enjoys them. Also, being that I live close to them, the only negative to this company is that it is a hindrance to any of my diet attempts! It’s hard to resist amazing cupcakes at good prices when they are only walking distance away from you when she is selling them from her food trailer. Plus, a portion of her proceeds go to support an orphanage in Uganda that her brothers were adopted from. So not only do you get amazing desserts, you also help support a worthwhile cause. Not often that you can get a WIN WIN situation like that! You can’t make everyone happy and some people are never happy with what they get so take that in consideration when reading any negative reviews for Cutie Pie Cupcakes. I have ordered stuff from her for years and never disappointed. She does an amazing job, especially considering how young she is!
McKenzie did an absolutely amazing job on my wedding cut cake! I gave her an inspo picture and she made it better than I could have imagined! On top of that the cake tasted amazing! If you are looking for cupcakes or cakes for an event Cutie pie cupcakes is the way to go!
McKenzie from Cutie Pie Cupcakes did an awesome job for my son’s 1st birthday smash cake and cupcakes! I sent her a few different inspiration photos and she took off running from there! She was great to work with, the product was delicious and she was flexible in the time I had to pick them up! Will definitely use her again and have already given her name to family and friends, as well.
For my 21st birthday I wanted to have cupcakes made of my favorite Pokemon! After dong the research on custom cake places around my area, I decided on Mackenzie and her cakes! They were adorable and tasted phenomenal! Will definitely be going back for all my custom cake needs!
We had such a great experience ordering my daughter’s smash cake from McKenzie. She was easy to work with and made the whole process smooth and stress-free. The smash cake and matching cupcakes turned out beautiful — exactly what I had envisioned. They were also delicious, everyone loved them! I’m so happy with how everything turned out and would absolutely order from her again!
I had a birthday cake made for my sister’s 16th birthday and it turned out amazing! I submitted what I wanted on the website then they reached out to me to talk about what I wanted. I sent them inspo pics and they did not disappoint! It’s beautiful and tasted great. I paid $65 for it which I thought was a great price for a cake.
I recently ordered a cake from Cutie Pie Cupcakes for my son’s 2nd birthday party, and I can’t express how thrilled I am with the result! The cake was a stunning centerpiece, featuring adorable safari animals along with my son’s name and age, which made it incredibly special. Not only was the design perfect, but the cake itself was moist and delicious. The cream cheese icing paired beautifully with the carrot cake, creating a delightful flavor combination that everyone raved about. It was truly a hit at the party! The service was exceptional as well. The owner went above and beyond, even delivering the cake right to our venue. I’m so impressed with the entire experience and can’t recommend Cutie Pie Cupcakes enough. I’ll definitely be returning for future celebrations! A solid 10 out of 10! 🎉🐾
Common questions about Cutie pie cupcakes
Cutie pie cupcakes is located at 624 E Main St Ext, Grove City, PA 16127, United States, Grove City, PA, United States.
You can reach Cutie pie cupcakes by calling +1 724-734-7003.
Cutie pie cupcakes has a rating of 4.8 out of 5 based on 46 customer reviews.
Cutie pie cupcakes features the following accessibility: Wheelchair-accessible car park.
Cutie pie cupcakes features the following service options: Delivery, Takeaway.
Business Features
In Your Area
★ 4.90
1.2 km away
★ 4.70
2.2 km away
★ 4.70
2.3 km away
★ 5.00
2.4 km away
★ 2.70
3.1 km away
3.1 km away
We look forward to welcoming you. Make a reservation or stop by - walk-ins welcome!
Request a table and we'll confirm your booking shortly.